Background

Interests vs positions: Getting to Yes

Behind what someone demands there is a reason — and two reasons often fit together better than two demands.

Evidence Core well supported, the package practice wisdom

What the model says

Two sisters want the same orange. That is a position. One needs the peel for a cake, the other wants the fruit for its juice — those are interests, and they fit together. Roger Fisher and William Ury built a school of negotiation on that observation: “Getting to Yes”, principled negotiation.

Their principles: separate the people from the problem — hard on the matter, soft on the people. Look at interests, not positions. Develop several options before settling on one. And insist on checkable standards instead of pressure.

Add to that the question of your best alternative: what do you do if you do not reach an agreement? Whoever knows that needs neither to cling nor to cave.

Where it comes from

Roger Fisher and William Ury, “Getting to Yes” (1981), from the second edition with Bruce Patton. It grew out of the Harvard Negotiation Project, which the authors founded in 1979. Ury's “Getting Past No” (1991) deals with difficult counterparts.

The core — negotiating over interests more often leads to solutions that serve both sides — is well supported in experimental negotiation research (for instance De Dreu, Weingart and Kwon 2000). The book as a package is practice wisdom with cultural limits: it assumes both sides can and want to talk openly about interests.

What you can do with it before the conversation

  1. Ask “what for” twice

    What do you want? And what for? What does the other person want — and what for? Two lines per side. Usually there is an interest behind both positions that does not exclude the other.

  2. Three options before you demand one

    Whoever goes into the conversation with a single solution negotiates over yes or no. With three proposals that serve both interests, you negotiate over how.

  3. Know your alternative

    What happens if you do not agree — and is that better or worse than what the other side is likely to offer? That question takes the edge off the fear.

Interests vs positions: examples

A position is what someone says they want. An interest is why they want it. Next to the orange, Fisher and Ury's best-known example is the library: two men argue about a window. One wants it open, the other shut. The librarian asks why. One wants fresh air, the other wants no draught. She opens a window in the next room — fresh air without a draught. (The story goes back to Mary Parker Follett.)

At home

Position: “We're going to my parents for Christmas.” — “No, we're staying home.” Interests: she wants her parents to see the children; he wants a few quiet days after a hard year. Options: her parents come for two days after Christmas, or a short visit on the 24th and home by the evening.

With a flatmate

Position: “No guests on weeknights.” Interest: sleep before an early shift. Option: guests are fine until ten on weeknights, in the living room rather than the kitchen next to the bedroom. The conversation itself is on asking your roommate to be quiet.

At work

Position: “I need the whole team on my project.” — “You get two people.” Interests: the project lead fears missing a client deadline; the head of department needs cover for daily operations. Option: two people full time, plus a third for the two weeks before the deadline.

In politics

Fisher and Ury's large-scale example is the Sinai at the Egyptian-Israeli talks at Camp David in 1978. The positions — who keeps how much of the peninsula — did not fit. The interests did: Israel wanted security, Egypt sovereignty. The agreement returned the Sinai to Egypt under the Egyptian flag and demilitarised large parts of it.

The four principles of principled negotiation, and BATNA

Separate the people from the problem

Feelings, perceptions and the relationship are handled on their own, not traded against the matter. You can be clear about the noise and friendly to the flatmate.

Focus on interests, not positions

Ask what for, and say your own what for. “What matters to you about that?” gets further than a bare “why?”.

Invent options for mutual gain

Collect several options before judging any. Inventing and deciding are two separate steps. This is the chapter in which Fisher and Ury tell the story of the orange.

Insist on objective criteria

Agree on a standard both can check — a house rule, a market price, a date — instead of whoever pushes harder.

BATNA: your best alternative

BATNA stands for best alternative to a negotiated agreement: what you will do if you do not agree. It is the yardstick for every offer. Better than your BATNA, consider it; worse, you can say no calmly. For the flatmate it might be earplugs and a word with the landlord; for a salary talk, the other job offer. Improve your BATNA before the conversation, and think about the other side's too.

Typical mistakes with interests and positions

  • Asking “why?” like an interrogator. “What is important to you about it?” sounds like interest, not a cross-examination.
  • Guessing the other side's interest and announcing it: “You just want control.” That is a label, not a question.
  • Opening with your one solution, so the conversation can only be about yes or no.
  • Treating your BATNA as a threat. You know your alternative; you do not wave it around.
  • Negotiating over respect or trust as if they were options. Those need their own conversation.
  • Splitting the difference too fast. Half an orange each serves neither the cake nor the juice.

Practice: from position to interest in ten minutes

  1. Write your position in the current conflict in one sentence, and the other person's.
  2. Under each, ask “what for?” twice and write down the answers.
  3. Circle the interests that do not exclude each other.
  4. Write three options that serve at least one interest on each side.
  5. Write your BATNA in one line. Then take the best option into the wizard as your request, and prepare the other person's first objection with an if-then plan.

Where the Conflict Simulator uses it

In the step “The other side” of the wizard there are two lines: “What do they want?” and “And what for? What is behind it?” Your answer goes onto the conversation card under “The other side”. The agreement at the end — who, what, by when, when do we check — is the checkable standard from the same approach.

The card “What you want – and why” tells the orange on one page. In the practice room the counterpart holds a position, and the coach asks what interest might be behind it.

Practise in the browser

Limits

Not every conflict is a negotiation. Where it is about hurt, respect or trust, the search for “options” feels cold, and the relationship level goes unsaid. The approach also assumes a degree of equal footing; with a strong power imbalance its principles do not carry, and threats are not a negotiation problem at all but a reason to get help. And “hard on the matter” is heard as an attack on the person in some cultures.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between interests and positions?

A position is the concrete demand someone makes: “I want the window open.” An interest is the reason behind it: “I need fresh air.” Positions often exclude each other; interests can usually be served at the same time.

What is principled negotiation?

Principled negotiation is the method Roger Fisher and William Ury describe in “Getting to Yes” (1981). It rests on four principles: separate the people from the problem, focus on interests rather than positions, invent options for mutual gain, and insist on objective criteria.

What does BATNA mean?

BATNA stands for best alternative to a negotiated agreement. It is what you will do if the negotiation fails, and it tells you which offers are worth accepting. The term comes from “Getting to Yes”.

What is the orange example in Getting to Yes?

Two sisters quarrel over one orange and finally split it in half. One eats her half and throws away the peel; the other uses only the peel for a cake. Had they talked about interests instead of positions, each could have had all of what she needed.

Does Getting to Yes work in personal relationships?

For practical disputes such as holidays, money or housework, the question about interests works well between partners and friends. Where the conflict is about hurt or trust, it needs a conversation about feelings first. With threats or a strong imbalance of power, negotiation is not the right frame.

Sources

Try it on your own sentence

Write the first sentence you would say. The simulator’s rules read along and show which words put the other person on the defensive.

No sentence yet. The flagged words and the question to ask yourself appear here.